Skip to content

Standards

How the engine works

Some Dorworth News stories are written automatically from the public record: a document published in the Federal Register, a figure an agency releases at its scheduled minute. Every one is labeled Automatic, carries its own receipt, and publishes only after code and at least two independent models agree that it matches its source.

The publisher publishes every reported story and answers for it. An automatic story is published by the engine when it passes every check, and no person approves it. Each automatic story says so and links to its receipt.


The record

Published
0
Held before publication
1
A check or a reviewer failed it; nothing held is edited into print by hand.
Corrected
0
Withdrawn
0
Proving runs, clean
67
Proving runs, failed
19

The time from a source’s publication to ours is reported here once the engine has published. Counted from the engine’s records, .


Each kind of story

A kind of story is promoted under this rule, and every receipt shows which part of it a run answers to.

  1. 1.

    What is counted. A kind is promoted after ten clean proving runs in a row: nine replays, then one live proving run. A run is clean when its story passes the whole gate and matches its answer key.

  2. 2.

    A replay uses only what the source had published at that moment. Its input is the release as the agency issued it, read from the agency’s own archive, with every figure at its first-published value. A replay fed from a series as it stands today is void, because agencies revise their figures after release. The answer key, the figures and facts the story must report, is taken from the archived release by a separate program, never by the engine’s writer. It is checked against the agency’s own table of first estimates where the agency publishes one, as the Bureau of Labor Statistics does for payrolls.

  3. 3.

    The nine replays are releases the kind has never seen. Releases used while a kind is being built are practice and are never counted. If a counted replay fails and the kind is changed to fix it, the count returns to zero and nine fresh releases are drawn.

  4. 4.

    Hard cases. Each kind has a written list of past releases that would trip a careless writer, shown on the engine’s page. Every hard case is clean before the count begins, and again whenever the kind changes. For the jobs report the list holds at least: a release whose earlier months were revised sharply; an annual benchmark revision; a month with a loss; a month whose rate did not change; a release the agency delayed, cancelled or combined, as around the 2025 federal shutdown; and a release the agency later corrected.

  5. 5.

    The live proving run. At the next real release the engine writes the story in real time and puts it through the whole gate, and the story is not published. A clean live proving run promotes the kind. Its first published story is the one after.

  6. 6.

    Versions. Every run records the exact versions of the source reader, the writer, each reviewer, the instructions and the checks. When any of them changes, the kind runs its hard cases and its nine counted replays again before it publishes another story, and a changed source reader also needs one clean live proving run. If all are clean, it carries on. Any failure pauses it.

  7. 7.

    Proving runs never leave the proving ground. Replay or live, they reach no wire, feed, sitemap, IndexNow notice, alert, edition of the Brief or search result. The publishing step refuses any story from a proving run. A replay’s story can be read from its receipt, under a banner that says what it is, on a page search engines are told not to index.

  8. 8.

    After promotion nothing is relaxed. Every story passes the whole gate every time. A story that fails a check is held. A held story, a correction of the engine’s own error or a withdrawal pauses the kind by itself, and the engine’s page says when and why. A paused kind publishes nothing new; what it has published stays, with any correction. The failing release joins the hard cases, and the kind earns promotion again from the start. A release the engine could not reach is a miss, not a failure: it is logged, retried and shown on the coverage page, and it does not pause the kind.

  9. 9.

    The order. Presidential documents and the national debt are promoted first. The jobs report and the inflation report follow. No monthly report makes its first public appearance on the day the wire is switched on.

Each kind of story: its state under the proving rule, its runs and its versions
KindStateHard casesReplaysLive proving runsPublished and heldLast failureVersions
Presidential documents (Federal Register)Proving on replays0 of 90 of 900 published0 held: People: A name outside the naming rule: Border Protection. The engine names only officials, candidates, companies and people acting in an office the filing names.
  • fr.presidential-document reader 4.3
  • Writer claude-sonnet-5-5
  • Reviewer claude-opus-5-5 (facts)
  • Reviewer claude-opus-5-5 (neutrality)
  • house rules 17.5
  • twelve checks 17.7, answer key 4.1
The national debt (Treasury, Debt to the Penny)Proving on replays0 of 60 of 900 published0 held: Fact review: The reviewer’s support for “Total public debt outstanding rose by $274.81 billion between Sept. 29, 2023 and Oct. 2, 2023.” is not in the source.
  • treasury.debt reader 4.1
  • Writer claude-sonnet-5-5
  • Reviewer claude-opus-5-5 (facts)
  • Reviewer claude-opus-5-5 (neutrality)
  • house rules 17.5
  • twelve checks 17.7, answer key 4.1
The jobs report (Bureau of Labor Statistics)Proving on replays0 of 70 of 900 published0 held: Fact review: Unsupported: “The report revised its estimates for the two months before November.”.
  • bls.empsit reader 4.3
  • Writer claude-sonnet-5-5
  • Reviewer claude-opus-5-5 (facts)
  • Reviewer claude-opus-5-5 (neutrality)
  • house rules 17.5
  • twelve checks 17.7, answer key 4.1
Consumer prices (Bureau of Labor Statistics)Proving on replays0 of 80 of 900 published0 held: Neutrality review: The source note: The note omits the release's pandemic caveat. Personal-visit price collection had been suspended since March 2020, more prices were imputed, many indexes rest on fewer collected prices than usual, and some normally published indexes were not published for November
  • bls.cpi reader 4.3
  • Writer claude-sonnet-5-5
  • Reviewer claude-opus-5-5 (facts)
  • Reviewer claude-opus-5-5 (neutrality)
  • house rules 17.5
  • twelve checks 17.7, answer key 4.1
GDP (Bureau of Economic Analysis)Proving on replaysWritten when its proving ground is built0 of 900 published0 heldNone
  • bea.gdp reader (no proving ground yet)
  • Writer claude-sonnet-5-5
  • Reviewer claude-opus-5-5 (facts)
  • Reviewer claude-opus-5-5 (neutrality)
  • house rules 17.5
  • twelve checks 17.7
Retail sales (Census Bureau)Proving on replaysWritten when its proving ground is built0 of 900 published0 heldNone
  • census.retail reader (no proving ground yet)
  • Writer claude-sonnet-5-5
  • Reviewer claude-opus-5-5 (facts)
  • Reviewer claude-opus-5-5 (neutrality)
  • house rules 17.5
  • twelve checks 17.7
Housing starts (Census Bureau)Proving on replaysWritten when its proving ground is built0 of 900 published0 heldNone
  • census.housing-starts reader (no proving ground yet)
  • Writer claude-sonnet-5-5
  • Reviewer claude-opus-5-5 (facts)
  • Reviewer claude-opus-5-5 (neutrality)
  • house rules 17.5
  • twelve checks 17.7
Weekly jobless claims (Labor Department)Proving on replaysWritten when its proving ground is built0 of 900 published0 heldNone
  • dol.claims reader (no proving ground yet)
  • Writer claude-sonnet-5-5
  • Reviewer claude-opus-5-5 (facts)
  • Reviewer claude-opus-5-5 (neutrality)
  • house rules 17.5
  • twelve checks 17.7
The price of gasoline (Energy Information Administration)Proving on replaysWritten when its proving ground is built0 of 900 published0 heldNone
  • eia.gasoline reader (no proving ground yet)
  • Writer claude-sonnet-5-5
  • Reviewer claude-opus-5-5 (facts)
  • Reviewer claude-opus-5-5 (neutrality)
  • house rules 17.5
  • twelve checks 17.7
The Fed’s rate decision (FOMC statement)Proving on replaysWritten when its proving ground is built0 of 900 published0 heldNone
  • fed.fomc reader (no proving ground yet)
  • Writer claude-sonnet-5-5
  • Reviewer claude-opus-5-5 (facts)
  • Reviewer claude-opus-5-5 (neutrality)
  • house rules 17.5
  • twelve checks 17.7

Hard cases: Presidential documents (Federal Register)

  • 2025-01901

    Executive Order 14148 of Jan. 20, 2025, Initial Rescissions of Harmful Executive Orders and Actions: it revokes dozens of earlier orders and actions, each by its own number.

  • 2025-01759

    Executive Order 14146, Partial Revocation of Executive Order 13961: signed on Jan. 19, 2025, by the president then in office, and published on Jan. 24, 2025, after the next one took office.

  • R1-2026-03829

    The Federal Register’s republication of Executive Order 14388 of Feb. 20, 2026, Continuing the Suspension of Duty-Free De Minimis Treatment for All Countries, on April 9, 2026: a correction of a document already published, not a new order.

  • 2025-02833

    Proclamation 10896, Adjusting Imports of Steel Into the United States: long, with an annex and tariff rates.

  • 2025-06063

    Executive Order 14257, reciprocal tariffs, with an annex of rates by country.

  • 2024-02844

    A notice continuing the national emergency with respect to Burma: written to a formula, and not a new emergency.

  • 2023-00985

    A memorandum delegating authority under section 506(a)(1) of the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961: no number, and technical.

  • 2025-18709

    A presidential order, Designating Antifa as a Domestic Terrorist Organization: an uncommon kind of document, on a contested subject.

  • 2025-10392

    The sequestration order for fiscal year 2026: percentages and sections of law in a document story.

Hard cases: The national debt (Treasury, Debt to the Penny)

  • During the 2021 debt-limit period, after the Labor Day weekend: the total fell $38.9 million over four days.

  • The first business day after the debt limit was suspended on June 3, 2023: up $358.6 billion over a weekend.

  • The first business day of fiscal year 2024: intragovernmental holdings up $266.0 billion in a day.

  • The first close above $35 trillion.

  • The first business day after the July 4, 2025, law raised the limit, after a holiday weekend: up $366.4 billion, the largest rise between two days in the records from 2021 on.

  • The first business day of 2026: down $91.2 billion, the largest fall between two days in the records from 2021 on, after the New Year holiday.

Hard cases: The jobs report (Bureau of Labor Statistics)

  • December 2020: payrolls fell by 140,000, and the unemployment rate was unchanged at 6.7 percent.

  • January 2025, with the annual benchmark revision of the establishment survey.

  • April 2025, which the bureau later corrected: it reissued the release on June 3, 2025, with a note on minor errors in the household survey’s April data, and published corrected estimates on June 6, 2025. Read as first issued; the reissue is the source’s own revision.

  • May 2025: the unemployment rate unchanged at 4.2 percent; March and April revised down by 95,000 combined.

  • July 2025: May and June revised down by 258,000 combined.

  • September 2025, published more than six weeks late because of the federal government shutdown.

  • November 2025, delayed by the shutdown: the first estimates for both October and November, and no household survey for October 2025.

Hard cases: Consumer prices (Bureau of Labor Statistics)

  • June 2022: up 1.3 percent in the month and 9.1 percent over 12 months.

  • July 2022: the all items index unchanged in the month.

  • December 2022: the index fell 0.1 percent, a change the next year’s seasonal factors revised.

  • January 2023, with the year’s new seasonal factors: December 2022 now an increase of 0.1 percent.

  • September 2025, published late because of the lapse in appropriations.

  • November 2025: no October 2025 survey, so a change over the two months from September.

  • October 2026: no 12-month change could be published, as October 2025 was not collected.

  • (joined the list when it failed)

    It failed in cycle 6: The counted replay of the release of 2020-12-10 failed after 1 clean in a row; the count returns to zero, and nine fresh releases are drawn when the kind changes.


Seven steps, and code does five of them

  1. 1.

    Read. A scheduled job fetches the source on the schedule its terms allow and keeps the answer exactly as received, with the time and a fingerprint of the file. Nothing kept is changed afterward.

  2. 2.

    Detect. The new answer is compared with the one before. A change becomes an event: an order published, a figure released. No change, no event, and the same document read twice is one event.

  3. 3.

    Judge. Code scores the event from 0 to 100 and gives the reasons. The score decides whether it becomes a story, a line in its desk’s roundup, or only a changed page.

  4. 4.

    The fact sheet. Code computes every figure, name, date and comparison the story may use, each tied to the sentence or table cell it came from.

  5. 5.

    Write. A model writes the headline, the summary and the body. In a story built on figures it never types a number: it names each figure, and code fills in the stored value. In a story built on a document, every sentence must come with the passage that supports it, and code confirms that passage is in the document word for word. In the story’s text, each such sentence carries a note that opens the document’s text on dorworth.com at its passage.

  6. 6.

    The gate. Twelve code checks, then models other than the writer that see only the story and its source. Any failure holds the story.

  7. 7.

    Publish. Only then does the story go out on the wire, under the Dorworth News Service byline, with its receipt.


The gate

Every story, every time, passes twelve checks written in code (Shape, Numbers, Arithmetic, Names, Quotations, Dates, Source, Freshness, Duplicate, Language, People, Rights): a figure that is not in the source, a verb that disagrees with the sign of a change, a quotation that does not match the source character for character, a date that is not the source’s, a document not read from the issuing body’s own address, a person outside the naming rule. Nothing is sampled and nothing is waived.

Then models review it, and never the model that wrote it. One lists every claim and quotes the source that supports each; one unsupported claim holds the story. Another looks for interpretation, loaded words and cause and effect the source does not state. On a major story, reviewers from other companies check it too. A reviewer that does not answer is never skipped: the story waits.

Source text is always handed to the models as material, never as instructions, and a sentence can rest only on the document’s own words, so a document carrying text written to look like a command cannot steer a story.


The receipt, corrections and withdrawals

Every automatic story carries How this story was made, linked to its receipt: a page for each run that shows the kind of run and the part of the rule it answers to; the record the story was written from, with the time it was retrieved and its fingerprint, so anyone can confirm the copy; the facts the story used, each with the passage it came from; each check and its result; each reviewer and its verdict, by the model’s exact name; the versions the run used; and the time of each step, from the source’s publication to ours. The same record is data at the story’s address with /json after it.

Three words are kept apart. Corrected: we published something wrong and fixed it. Revised by the source: the source changed its own record; what we published was right when we published it. Withdrawn: we took a story down; its page stays and says why. When a source revises a figure or reissues a document, the story keeps what it published and carries a dated note, Revised by the source, saying what changed; the revision is listed on the corrections page, and the next story reports it. When the engine got something wrong, the story is corrected in place and marked Corrected. An editor can withdraw a story with a reason. Every publication, hold, correction, revision and withdrawal is written to the newsroom’s tamper-evident audit log under the engine’s own name.

The engine never writes under a reporter’s byline, states an opinion, a forecast or a cause the source does not state, names a private person, invents a quotation or a figure, or calls a model when a reader opens a page.


Where the dates come from

The calendar is read from the official calendars below, each on its own schedule. Every read is recorded with its time, the address read and a fingerprint of what came back, and every entry links to the schedule it came from.

Holidays, tax day, hurricane season and the Legislature’s session dates are entered by hand, each from its official page, and each entry says the day that page was checked.

The same event listed by two calendars is one entry, at the time the more authoritative calendar gives, naming both: a House hearing on both the House’s own calendar and Congress.gov is shown once, as the House lists it. When a calendar moves an event, the entry keeps its address and says where it moved from, and its page keeps every earlier time. An event a calendar cancels leaves the lists, and its page says Cancelled by its source. An event that no calendar lists any longer also leaves the lists, but it is not called cancelled: its page says No longer listed by its source, with the date it was last seen, because a calendar can drop an event without saying why.

Times are shown in each reader’s own time zone, with the zone named, and in Eastern when scripts are turned off. The subscription files give each timed event at its instant in UTC, so no calendar shifts it across a change to or from daylight saving time; an event whose source announces no time is listed for the whole day, and an event has an end only when its source gives one. In the files a cancelled event is marked cancelled and an event no longer listed is marked tentative, so a subscribed calendar updates the entry it already has. Every scheduled economic release names the kind of automatic story that will cover it, and the engine watches for it at that minute, as the numbers library below describes.


The numbers library

Every figure on the numbers pages is read from the agency that publishes it, and every value is kept as each release published it: when a later release revises a month, the revised value is kept beside the first one, and the figure’s page shows both. A month an agency did not publish is shown as a gap, never as a zero.

For each new reading the library computes the change from the period before, the comparison with a year earlier, whether it is the highest or lowest since a given date, how long a run in one direction has lasted, and how unusual the move is against the figure’s own history. That last measure is set against the middle of the figure’s past moves rather than their average, so one freak month cannot make every later move look ordinary. A change in a rate is written in percentage points, never in percent.

When a scheduled release is due, the engine checks the agency’s page every twenty seconds from the scheduled minute until the release appears, then writes and checks the story at once, and publishes it when that kind of story is publishing; a step that fails is retried from the queue. The weekly jobless claims are watched from 8:30 a.m. Eastern each Thursday, and the Fed’s statement from 1:59 p.m. to 3:30 p.m. on a decision day, the time each statement confirms. For the jobs report, consumer prices and the Fed’s decision, the Business desk’s own draft of the release stays a draft for an editor, and no job publishes it. When an agency corrects a release after publishing it, the story keeps what it published and carries a dated note, Revised by the source, that says what the agency changed.

  • Read from the minute the release is scheduled on the calendar until it appears, then hourly for a correction until 6 p.m. Eastern, and once on other days.

  • Read from the minute the release is scheduled on the calendar until it appears, then hourly for a correction until 6 p.m. Eastern, and once on other days.

  • Read from the minute the release is scheduled on the calendar until it appears, then hourly for a correction until 6 p.m. Eastern, and once on other days.

  • Read from the minute the release is scheduled on the calendar until it appears, then hourly for a correction until 6 p.m. Eastern, and once on other days.

  • Read from the minute the release is scheduled on the calendar until it appears, then hourly for a correction until 6 p.m. Eastern, and once on other days.

  • Read from 8:30 a.m. Eastern each Thursday until the week’s release appears, and once on other days.

  • Read from 10 a.m. Eastern on the day the page names for its next release, and once on other days.

Florida’s unemployment rate and payrolls and the Miami and Tampa price indexes are read once a day from the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ public data service; the weekly fuel prices’ longer history comes from the Energy Information Administration’s data service once its key is set.